The BMW X5 is now in it's third generation, but how does it stack up against its rivals?

Introduction

The X5 is BMW’s big, luxurious SUV, and the Munich company’s competitor for the likes of the Range Rover Sport and Mercedes-Benz GLE. This is the third generation of a lineage that stretches back to 1999. A controversial vehicle at the time, it has matured into a luxurious, sophisticated SUV. It’s not much good off-road – but that’s hardly the point nowadays, is it?

 

Body Style: SUV                Seats: 5                     MRP from £47,170 -  £63,175

 

Did you know? BMW actually re-used the chassis and platform of the MkII X5 of 2006 for this generation. Doesn’t seem to have harmed it.

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Verdict: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8.4/10)

The second-generation X5 was something of a disappointment but this model has been a roaring success. It looks deeply handsome, has a terrific-looking, high quality cabin and it’s more or less brilliant to drive. There’s a wide range of engines available, but in the end the default-choice 30d 3.0-litre diesel is the best one.

Design & Exterior

★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

Interior & Comfort

★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

Technology & Connectivity

★★★★★★★★★☆ (9/10)

Performance & Handling

★★★★★★★★★☆ (9/10)

Safety Features

★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

Specs & Trims

★★★★★★★★★☆ (9/10)

Running Costs & Fuel Economy

★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

Pricing

★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

 

2017 BMW X5

We Like

Smart styling

Gorgeous cabin
Engaging to drive

We Don't Like

Ride on the firm side

Optional extra seats are rather small
Plugin hybrid version has odd-feeling steering

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Design & Exterior: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

2017 BMW X5

Somehow, BMW has managed to create a large, imposing SUV that shares its handsome looks and lines with the 5 Series and 7 Series, in the process looking significantly less hulking and bulky than the rival Audi Q7. Its 5 Series-alike styling at the front also helps it to blend in a little better on crowded city streets, which is something of a boon in an era when ‘Chelsea Tractors’ are coming in for much criticism.

Image-wise, it’s pretty hard to beat. That original 1999 X5 was really the first large SUV that was in any real sense fun to drive, and while the second-gen dropped the ball on that front a touch, this current car has reclaimed the handling high ground. The original X5 effectively created the sporty, desirable SUV sector, and this model lives up to the legacy. But do most of the examples you see on the road really need tyres quite that wide?

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Interior & Comfort: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

2017 BMW X5

Just to qualify that eight-star rating ever so slightly – it’s spec-dependent. If you spend no time at all browsing the options list and just leave your X5’s cabin in basic black and silver, it looks a touch plain. A bit of effort with leather colours, wood or carbon fibre effect trims and so on, though, and you get a cabin that treads an almost perfect middle ground between the 5 Series and the 7 Series in its style, quality and comfort.

You sit up high, of course, but not so much that you feel as if you’re tottering. You get a great view out but the view inside is almost better, from the clear, concise instruments to the standard-fit BMW Professional sat-nav with its big 10.2-inch screen. It’s just a lovely space in which to exist.

Practicality

The X5 is hugely practical with one notable limitation. With 650 litres of luggage space it doesn’t have the biggest boot in the class (step forward the Audi Q7), but it should be more than sufficient for most needs. There’s also the option of two extra foldaway seats in the boot. The problem is that these seats, and indeed the main set of back seats, are all a bit short on ultimate space. Headroom is never an issue, but taller rear-seat passengers can sometimes feel short of legroom. Which they really shouldn’t in a car of this size.

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Technology & Connectivity: ★★★★★★★★★☆ (9/10)

2017 BMW X5

Exactly how much connectivity do you want or need? Well, the X5 can provide it. Quite apart from expected tech options such as a head-up display, smartphone connectivity and charging and a DAB radio, the X5 benefits from BMW’s suite of Connected Services. Those include the optional Mobile Office function which, depending on your phone of choice, can help you (safely and legally) manage emails, calendar entries, text messages and more. There’s a speech-to-text function for composing replies, plus the ability to integrate such apps as Spotify, Audible, Twitter and more into the infotainment system.

There’s also an integrated SIM card for the BMW Online Services package, which includes live weather and traffic, route planning from your home mobile devices and location-based information on restaurants, shopping, parking, fuel prices and more.

Finally, there’s a BMW Concierge service which, at the touch of a button, can help you find a hotel, a restaurant or some other service where you are or where you’re going, make a booking and even send the directions directly to your satnav.

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Performance & Handling: ★★★★★★★★★☆ (9/10)

2017 BMW X5

While the current X5 can’t quite match the sheer agility and fun factor of the 1999 original, it’s not far off. That’s quite a result for a heavier, roomier car with the option of extra seats in the boot.

The steering feels sharp and points that big, tall nose into corners with remarkable precision. The suspension’s control of the X5’s movements is fantastic, with an amazing ability to keep that hefty body level in corners, although that does come at the expense of ride quality. The X5 isn’t unyieldingly hard-edged, but the combination of stiff springs and run-flat tyres makes the X5 feel more firm than some of its rivals, especially around town.

Of the engines, the best by far is the 258hp '30d' 3.0-litre diesel, which has long been the go-to choice for X5 owners. It’s smooth, has more than enough power and torque (413lb ft of the latter) yet can be surprisingly frugal and low on emissions.

You can upgrade to the more powerful 313hp 40d version of the same 3.0-litre engine, which is hugely tempting (not least for its 464lb ft wallop of pulling ability), but is significantly more expensive. Both of those engines come with four-wheel drive as standard, but there is a more frugal rear-drive option, the 25d sDrive, using a twin-turbo 2.0-litre diesel engine with 231hp and 332lb ft of torque. It’s too good to be considered a poverty version, but it’s not as sweet as the 3.0-litre engines.

The range-topping diesel is the 3.0-litre M50d, which has a huge 381bhp and 545lb ft on tap.

Petrol fans can choose from a storming 450hp 4.4-litre turbo V8 (which is glorious, but whose running costs are beyond the realms of most pockets) or the 40e iPerformance plug-in hybrid. That combines a 2.0-litre turbo petrol engine with a plugin hybrid module, which is efficient if rather disappointing to drive compared to a standard X5.

Recommended engine: X5 30d xDrive 3.0

0-62 MPH

6.8secs

Fuel economy

47.9mpg

Emissions

156g/km

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Safety Features: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

2017 BMW X5

The current X5 has not been tested by Euro NCAP for crash safety, but the previous model BMW 5 Series, which shares part of its structure and mechanical package with the X5, scored a maximum five-star rating. So the omens for the X5 are good, as far as such comparisons allow.

The X5 also comes stuffed with the latest in driver assistance technologies, including lane departure warning and steering correction, forward collision warning and autonomous braking with vehicle and pedestrian detection. The X5 additionally has a full stability, traction and cornering brake control set-up, active cornering headlights, run-flat tyres, rain sensors, auto-dipping main beam headlights (with LED lights available as an option), active cruise control with a traffic jam function able to take over braking, steering and acceleration in heavy traffic, a blind spot detection system, and a driver attention monitor.

You want more? How about an infra-red night vision camera? Rear-seat entertainment package? Bang & Olufsen sound system? All options.

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Specs and Trim Levels: ★★★★★★★★★☆ (9/10)

2017 BMW X5

Colours
Effectively there’s no limit to what colour and trim you can pick for the X5 because, if your pockets are deep enough, you can use the BMW Individual service that will do almost anything you want, for a sufficient fee.

As standard, however, you can choose from non-metallic black or Alpine White, or metallic Sophisto Grey Xirallic, Glacier Silver, Space Grey, Sparkling Brown Xirallic, Atlas Silver, Imperial Blue Xirallic, Black Sapphire, Carbon Black, Individual Pearl Silver Metallic, Individual Ruby Black Metallic, Individual Pyrite Brown Metallic or Individual Azurite Black Metallic.

Trims

Essentially there are just two trim levels for the X5 – SE and M Sport, but to those you can add sub-level trims Pure Experience Design or Pure Excellence Design. Experience includes 19-inch alloy wheels, matt chrome and matt aluminium exterior finishers, Mocha Nappa leather upholstery, textured wood trim and a sports three-spoke steering wheel.

The Excellence also comes with 19-inch wheels, has bright chrome or aluminium exterior trim, ivory white Nappa leather, high-gloss oak wood trim and deeper carpets.

All models come with, at minimum, Xenon headlights, an electric split tailgate, LED fog lights and rear lamps, dual-zone climate control, DAB radio, cruise control, Bluetooth, leather upholstery, part-electric seats, ‘Professional’ satnav with live traffic and emergency services calling function.

M Sport adds a chunky body kit, quad exhausts, fully electric leather and Alcantara seats, and adaptive M Sport suspension.

Specs

The list of options for the X5 is close to endless, but you can keep things relatively simple and still have a decent specification. Standard kit is pretty good, but we’d add the Experience Design pack, plus some key safety options such as active cruise control and lane departure, plus the adaptive LED lights. Stick to a relatively sober grey or black metallic, as few secondhand buyers care for the brighter colour options.

Size & Dimensions

You’ll need a big garage, because it’s not a small car. It does come with front and rear parking sensors as standard, which helps, and there are optional camera systems and a self-parking assistant that can ease your stress in tight confines.

Length

4,886 mm

Width

2,184 mm

Height

1,762 mm

Max towing weight without brake

From 750kg - 3,500kg

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Running Costs & Fuel Economy : ★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

2017 BMW X5

No big SUV is ever going to be a star performer in this category, at least not in real-world terms. The obvious star performer is the 40e plugin hybrid, which has remarkable official figures of 85mpg and 77g/km of CO2, plus up to 19 miles on pure electric power once you’ve fully charged the batteries. The reality is rather more disappointing, with a real-world figure in mixed use closer to 30-35mpg. If you live in town and only use the car for short, electric only hops, then it could be for you.

The rest of us should stick to the 3.0-litre 30d engine. A figure of 156g/km isn’t perhaps the most impressive in this day and age, but it will return a realistic 35-40mpg overall, and will probably do better in daily driving than the more stressed 25d 2.0-litre engine. Once you start adding power, such as with the M50d, you’re into 173g/km territory, although the petrol V8 50i engine has surprisingly trim emissions of 224g/km or thereabouts, depending on the choice of alloy wheel.

Surprisingly, upgrading to the more powerful 40d diesel engine doesn’t carry a particularly big penalty – its emissions are rated at 157g/km.

Reliability and servicing

The current X5 has not yet been subjected to any recalls, and you can avail yourself of BMW’s service-inclusive programme that covers the standard servicing costs for the first three years. 

Petrol models

Every 9,000 miles - prices from £219 est.

Diesel models

Every 12,000 miles - prices from £179 est.

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Pricing: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ (8/10)

2017 BMW X5

As with almost any BMW, the X5 is not what you’d call cheap. You can get a basic X5 25d sDrive for £47,170 (and maybe a bit less if you haggle – it’s not the most popular model). An M Sport version of the same will set you back £50,370 while seven-seat versions will cost £48,580 (SE) or £51,780 (M Sport).

A 30d SE starts from £52,260 (five-seat) or £53,670 (seven-seat) while an M Sport 3.0-litre starts from £56,245 (£57,235 for the seven-seat). Prices for the 40d kick off at £54,920 for an SE five-seat (£56,330 for seven-seat) and £58,905 for an M Sport five-seat (£59,985 for the seven-seater).

The top-spec M50d diesel starts at £67,220 (the seven-seater costs £68,210) while the 40e plugin hybrid starts at £54,820 for the SE or £58,805 for the M-Sport (and there’s no seven-seat version).

The range-topping 50i starts at £62,630 for an SE or £64,040 for an M Sport, while a seven-seat SE is £64,040 and a seven-seat M Sport is £68,495.

 

Verdict | Design | Interior | Technology | Performance | Safety | Specs | Running Costs | Pricing

Recommendations

NEW PARENTS

1.6 JTDM – Stylish, safe, and frugal

GREEN CAR BUYER

1.4 168bhp TCT – Proves you don't need diesel for low emissions

CAR ENTHUSIAST

Veloce – Not as polished as Golf GTI, but it's drop dead gorgeous

Rivals

Audi Q7

The default choice in this class. Not engaging to drive, but sumptuous quality

Range Rover Sport

Share rear-drive chassis and terrific quality, but it's not what you'd call pretty

Lexus RX 450h

Posh Citroen hatch looks smart and is roomy, but it’s not good to drive and quite pricey.

Mercedes-Benz GLE

Slightly cramped inside, but good to drive. Awkward dash design, though.

Porsche Cayenne

Beats even the BMW for driver appeal and it’s less ugly than before, but no seven-seater.

Volvo XC90

Can’t compete as a driver's car, but styling inside and out is terrific and it’s exceptionally roomy and safe.

What others say

What Car?           

“The Giulietta has a mildly sporty character, as befits the Alfa Romeo brand, but it ticks all the sensible boxes too, with a wide range of engines and trims.”

Car Buyer

“The Alfa Romeo Giulietta just about has enough style and pizzazz to make up for its average interior and poor ergonomics.”

 

2017 BMW X5