Drivers give the hard shoulder the snub even when it's open to traffic

More than half of British drivers say they avoid driving on the hard shoulder of smart motorways when it is open for traffic, new research has found.

A study of more than 2,000 UK motorists found that 56 percent said they would avoid using the hard shoulder at some points, even if the overhead signs indicated it was open for use. Assuming the survey sample is representative of the public as a whole, it could mean as many as 23.1 million people are failing to use the hard shoulder when it is open.

Of the respondents who admitted to avoiding the hard shoulder, almost a third (29 percent) said they did so because they were not sure when to use it, while a quarter (25 percent) said they were concerned there may be a stationary vehicle ahead. Meanwhile 15 percent said they were worried about picking up a puncture from debris on the hard shoulder, and just as many (also 15 percent) said they did not like to drive so close to the verge. Some 14 percent, however, said they wanted to use other lanes in order to have an “escape lane” should they need to move across quickly.

Evening traffic on the M1 motorway in Watford UK

But Kwik Fit says its findings reveal a general uncertainty of how to use smart motorways. One in five drivers (20 percent) said they didn’t know when the hard shoulder was in use, while 13 percent wrongly said you can never use the hard shoulder of a smart motorway. Just four in 10 drivers (42 percent) knew it was only possible to drive on the hard shoulder of a smart motorway when directed by overhead signs.

Perhaps worryingly, even fewer drivers could identify the overhead gantry symbol that tells drivers the hard shoulder is open for traffic. Just 29 percent of motorists correctly stated that a sign above the hard shoulder showing a speed limit indicates that it is to be used as a running lane. Kwik Fit itself expressed concern that the study found 15 percent of drivers believe a blank sign means the lane is open when it in fact means the lane is closed.

Evening traffic on busiest British motorway M25

“These findings reflect the concerns and uncertainty that many drivers have when driving on smart motorways,” said Roger Griggs, communications director of Kwik Fit. “It’s clear that if many drivers are avoiding using the hard shoulder when it’s open, then the extra capacity which smart motorways are designed to provide is not being utilised properly and we will end up being in a worse position than with the original road layout.

“It is vital that there is a nationwide information campaign to ensure that drivers fully understand when they can and cannot use the hard shoulder if smart motorways are to be accepted by drivers and provide a way to ease congestion – something we need desperately.”